I just can’t attend an event run by people that have helped kill everything that made Cambridge special
I am quite upset as I sit here writing this. Certain episodes in one’s life have a great power over one’s emotions even after the passage of decades. And dredging up painful old memories is never fun.
In this case, said memories involve my months as a homeless and quasi-homeless “pit kid” in the Harvard Square of the summer and fall of 1987 at ages 20 and 21. A time that was all the more crazy for me because I was living a double life as a left-wing political activist, working on an ultimately failed attempt to restart the Students for a Democratic Society organization (1960-1974) with many kids from rich families who had no idea where I was going at night after our meetings or rallies were over. Though they knew I had been expelled from Boston University for my role in the campus anti-apartheid movement the previous year and had just beat a federal rap in the “Northampton 15” trial in the spring after my being arrested for protesting CIA recruitment at UMass Amherst. Making relations with my hardworking middle-class family in the Boston burbs quite visibly rocky to say the least.
I resonated with Cambridge as early as 1980 because it was cool. Every teenager in the Boston area who did not want their lives to be the usual round of “Work Rest Play Die,” as the song by the UK anarchist hardcore band Subhumans put it, made their way to the “pit” area of the square—a multilevel brick and stone assemblage just outside the main entrance to the Harvard Square T … better suited to a suburban mall in the 1970s when it had first presumably been on some architect’s drawing board. Yet it was what it was. Ugly and uncomfortable or not, every artistic and political subculture of the period was represented there. Kids from every racial, ethnic, gender, and class background passed through. And many hung out in the pit repeatedly for periods of time ranging from a few days to a few years.
Cambridge was cool because cool people could afford to live in Cambridge in the era of rent control. Cool people being the ones who typically play a key role in creating new and interesting culture—enlivening and improving what would otherwise be a mundane existence for humankind as they go.
Many of those simultaneously charming and difficult creatives, not at all coincidentally, hail from working and middle class backgrounds. Making them exactly the kind of people that have been driven from Cambridge by the actions of some of the organizers of a “Pit-A-Palooza” event this weekend honoring the people they call “Pit Rats” (an appellation I don’t recall anyone I knew in the pit in my day ever using, my friends and I calling ourselves pit kids) and even going so far as to get the City of Cambridge to declare June 25, 2022 “Pit Rat Day.”
Notably, Harvard Square Business Association Executive Director Denise Jillson and Cambridge City Councilor (and former Mayor) Marc McGovern. Both of whom have been involved not just in current plans to physically destroy the pit by turning it into a plaza—a move I can actually understand, if not entirely sympathize with, on ADA accessibility grounds alone—but in quite literally destroying the proverbial goose that laid the golden egg of culture in Harvard Square between at least the 1960s and 1980s, depending on how one slices it, by effectively killing Cambridge. Turning it into a place that I have taken to calling “a simulacrum of a city.” A locale with no more uniqueness and spirit than Disneyworld at 2 a.m. on a Monday morning.
How? In Jillson’s case, she was one of the main shills working to help the real estate industry destroy rent control in not just Cambridge, where it actually existed and was wildly popular with everyone but landlords and capitalist ideologues, but throughout Massachusetts (in the vast majority of cities and towns where it didn’t exist) by heavily outspending renter advocates in a binding 1994 statewide referendum vote—and continues to inveigh against the reform to this day. In McGovern’s case, I have described him as “an archetypal neoliberal municipal politician,” when writing about his role in ensuring that the former East Cambridge Courthouse would be redeveloped into a bog-standard mixed-use commercial monstrosity (with 48 “affordable” apartments, excelsior!) instead of a desperately needed major public housing development in a city with little public land left to build public housing on and nearly zero political will to do so (as thousands sit on Cambridge’s public housing waiting lists). Both Jillson and McGovern doubtless have many other sins to atone for in the matter of changing Cambridge from a cultural mecca into a soulless playground for the wealthy and sociopathic, but the examples above suffice to make my point of the moment.
Still, I don’t want to overpersonalize my longstanding political animus toward Jillson and McGovern or try to say that only homeless pit kids were the real pit kids. Obviously, they and the other event organizers have some connection to and affection for the place or they wouldn’t bother doing a memorial event. And clearly, there have been huge numbers of crews over several decades, often overlapping, that can lay claim to being pit kids. Not to forget the growing numbers of older unhoused people who have lived rough in and around Harvard Square since even before the half-century lifespan of the pit—first arriving after the deinstitutionalization of Mass public mental hospitals began in the mid-70s. A policy crisis related to the rise of homelessness in Cambridge that I haven’t seen anyone mention in the announcements, articles, or social media discussions of this weekend’s pit-themed event.
But in the current buzz, I don’t recognize the place that my ever-shifting crew of about a dozen homeless or near-homeless pit kids claimed as our own in the late 80s. Where most of us worked service jobs in the square yet couldn’t even afford the cheaper rents of the period … while the Reagan administration had already wiped out most public jobs and housing programs that might have helped us. Where art was literally in the streets. Where we could have deep conversations about any conceivable topic for hours at any time of day or night. Where there was always some interesting show or reading or party or happening going on nearby that we could attend or crash. Where the owner of the now-shuttered Algiers Coffee House, Emile Durzi, and his staff would let us linger over tea when it was cold or raining out and give us baskets of pita bread for free, sometimes not even charging us for the drinks. Where I shouted “JUMP!” from my perch in front of Out of Town News to passing despondent business people as they got off the T when the market crashed one fine day. Where we had an organized theft ring and stole our bosses blind for stuff to exchange for stuff we needed from each other. Where we slept in the Common when it was nice—and the cops didn’t roust us—and anywhere we could (except the shelters that started popping up in that period) when it was not. Crashing at friends’ places until their roommates threw us out, if we were lucky. Where needle drugs were just starting to come back after being less prevalent in the square for a time. Where we got our medical treatment at the Bridge Over Troubled Waters medical van (donate to BOTW here). Where AIDS was an omnipresent threat for a bunch of hormone-driven young people and an automatic death sentence for those who got it.
Life on the streets had its great moments for my friends and I, but mostly it was hard and those of us that could manage to do so got away from it as fast as possible. By December 1987 I had found the first in a short series of very cheap and crappy rooms (in Watertown and Boston) that kept me indoors until I split the pit scene and Cambridge in June 1988 for another series of cheap places in Vermont for a couple of years. When I returned to the area in 1990, fully burying the hatchet with my long-suffering parents in the process, the pit kids I had known were mostly gone. And I had lost any interest in hanging out there.
For all that, I have a soft spot for the pit and its many crews and will be sad to see it paved over. But I simply cannot participate in what I consider to be a tone-deaf, ill-conceived celebration of its legacy.
I’m not telling anyone else to avoid the Pit-A-Palooza event, of course. However, any former pit kids of any generation that share my disquiet with the proceedings in question and would like to organize some alternative commemoration of the place that we all shaped as it shaped us are welcome to contact me at email@example.com. It would be nice to see folks who had some version of my experience on the streets of Harvard Square. And search for lost time together.
Apparent Horizon—an award-winning political column—is syndicated by the MassWire news service of the Boston Institute for Nonprofit Journalism. Jason Pramas is an aging bohemian of what is now the old school. He is also BINJ’s executive director, editor of the Somerville Wire, and executive editor and associate publisher of DigBoston.